Towertalk
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: [TowerTalk] Back of desk grounding buss

To: towertalk@contesting.com
Subject: Re: [TowerTalk] Back of desk grounding buss
From: K4SAV <RadioIR@charter.net>
Date: Tue, 25 Mar 2014 08:47:41 -0500
List-post: <towertalk@contesting.com">mailto:towertalk@contesting.com>
On 3/22/2014 5:16 PM, Jim Lux wrote:
I think we sometimes spend too much time worrying about lightning 
safety, and not enough about power line safety. I've seen ham shacks 
with all kinds of transient suppression on the coax, and automatic 
grounding relays for coax, and all manner of stuff.  But if there were 
to be a medium voltage to low voltage short on a neighborhood 
distribution transformer, the shack would essentially be destroyed.  
How much of your gear can take a 10-16kV overvoltage on the power cord?
I've had first hand experience of the latter kind of overvoltage 
twice! with substantial damage to appliances and wiring in both 
cases.  Once was an underground transformer with an internal fault, 
once was a wind induced failure of a MV feeder falling across the drop 
to the house. (I'm also lucky to live in southern California, where 
lightning is rare.  Those of you in Orlando probably have a different 
take on things <grin>.  )

Yep. Lived there 38 years and saw a lot of lightning damage. Every house on my block had damage at one time or another. A couple had holes blown in the roof. Antennas stood no chance at all if the grounding was poor. You guys in California live in a different world.
Even now living in an area (north Alabama) that generally has a lot less 
lightning, my little 70 (to top) tower takes a direct hit 2 to 3 time 
per year.  The problem is that I live on a small barren hill and my 
tower is the tallest thing around for a long distance.  Without good 
grounding, my house insurance would have been canceled in the first 2 or 
3 months.  I have yet to have any damage due to lightning, with many 
strikes.
What we really need in the area of lightning protection is education.  
On radio forums lightning protection is a very common question, usually 
more than one question per week.  When you look at all the answers, 
about 90% of them are wrong.  There are always "elmers" who are willing 
to recommend things when they don't have a clue as to what works.  Most 
of them recommend whatever they have and they have had no problems since 
they have never had a strike.  How is a noobe going to know what is 
right and what is wrong.
Even some of the better lightning books have serious errors.  I have sat 
thru several hamfest forums on lightning protection and listened to the 
presenters quoting errors from those books as facts.  A little education 
and common sense should have prevented this.
Even this forum isn't very good.  The obsession about back-of-the-desk 
bus bar is something that makes little difference for lightning 
protection.  When you are putting in large conductors at your desk to 
handle lightning currents, you have already lost the battle.  Large 
lightning currents inside your house is a recipe for disaster.  Proper 
grounding will keep all those high currents outside so you don't need 
big wires at the desk.  If you want a redundant ground at your desk for 
personnel protection against AC faults that's OK, but it's going to do 
nothing for lightning protection.
Jerry, K4SAV

_______________________________________________



_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk

<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>