Hello all....I have read all the comments carefully. Some I like and
some I hate. I think that is pretty normal for all of us.
However, I want to make a point that has only been touched on by one
other poster. There is a BIG difference between FT8(for tropo
contacts), MSK144(for meteor scatter), and JT65(for EME). Yes, they all
are "digital". And as Jay pointed out, "Rate is King".
MSK144 is normally used when the band is dead to any other method of
making a QSO. MSK is usually a very slow mode, quite often taking 15-20
min to make a contact. I cannot imagine someone using meteor scatter if
the band were open to any other mode, just because the rate is so slow.
Meteor scatter can and often does provide several "rare" grids that are
usually way out there and not possible via FT8. Meteor scatter is
normally run in the dead of night when even FT8 is a "no go". The
bottom line is that you can pick up some multipliers late at night, but
you will never set the contesting world on fire with MSK144.
JT65 is used for EME. EME is also a very slow mode. IF everything is
perfect, it takes 4 minutes to make a contact. Hence, it is
theoretically possible to make 15 contacts in an hour. In practice, you
will not even get close to that. So, the bottom line here is that the
rate for EME is really poor, even though you can pick up a few grids
that you could never get any other way.
Now let's turn our attention to FT8. Compared to Es, FT8 is a rate
killer, big time. Any decent contester knows that on Es, you can make a
QSO every 10 seconds or so. Hence, you can make 6 contacts in a
minute--hour after hour assuming that you have the stations on the other
end to work. Theoretically, FT8 requires 1 minute to make a contact.
In practice, if you get half that as an average, you are really doing well.
So why has FT8 swept everything else away? This is the BIG question
that needs considering. My Take: VHF Rookies have discovered that they
can make "DX" contacts on 6M via FT8. Rookies don't care about rate or
serious contesting, they just want to work DX easily. They get a few
new grids and maybe a new state or two and they are ecstatic! They are
not interested in building up a big station with big antennas and big
power. They get to work a few "difficult" contacts easily and cheaply.
This point of view is probably correct for them as long as they remain
casual operators. Since everyone needs to work the casual operators, we
are stuck operating the way that they operate, just to get them in the
logs. All this is a shame, because in the "good old days", the casual
operators would get down on the low end of 6M and when the band opened,
everyone worked everyone(just not on the same frequency). Rate was high
and the little pistols were able to work the big guns as well as the
other little pistols. Now, you cannot pry their cold dead fingers off
the FT8 button.
Well reasoned comments welcome. Flames go directly to the bit bucket,
will not pass GO, and will not collect $200.
I hope that everyone had a good contest this time. For us it was a hard
slog through the mud. But, January is always a hard slog.
73 to all...Marshall K5QE
_______________________________________________
VHFcontesting mailing list
VHFcontesting@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/vhfcontesting
|