I've had lots of experience stacking antennas....from monobanders, to
duobanders for WARC to tribanders.
I wouldn't think twice about putting up a stack for any band, if money and
labor was not an issue. I'd rather have two three element Yagis stacked
than on e 6 el at the top height. Why? Flexibility is the answer, as well
as maintenance.
Triband stacks? I had them out at KH6 at around 90/60/30 (KT36XA). Yes,
the middle one was probably not really a big contributor for gain on 20,
but the signal brought endless piles of EU and NA on that band, since the 90
over 30 was still in effect. 15 and 10 were where they really shined.
Granted I was on a nice big hill, but I could definitely tell how much better
the stack worked rather than just the top antenna. I also have the same
stack at my place now and although it is down a little from the 4 high
monoband stacks on 10, 15 and 20, it still is a very able performer.
If the sale of my house goes through the triband stack will be employed at
my new QTH in the Caribbean.
K4XS
In a message dated 2/24/2015 12:11:45 A.M. Coordinated Universal Tim,
rxdesign@ssvecnet.com writes:
Hello Rich, I’m not sure if this will be inline with the thread you’ve
created, a new thread or somewhere entirely separate... sorry if not
inline
where I intended it to be.
I've had what you're planning on doing - a 3 stack of C31's. See the
picture
on QRZ.com call sign search (K9RX). It was taken down in April of 2012
after
having been up for 6 1/2 years (we moved).
I can tell you that first off there are few times that a separate antenna
will be better than the stack. On 10 meters it would happen occasionally,
15
less often and 20 probably less than a couple times all told! I had
antennas
at 41, 81, 121. I felt this was the best overall spacing. If I had it to
do
over again I'd probably reduce it to 37' or so as it really is too far
apart
on 10 and for a relatively short boom 20 if you model it you can find that
37' is a slight increase in gain over 40' (with a slight reduction in FB).
So using single or dual stacks just isn't something you'll end up doing
much
of. There's too much coupling into the non-connected antennas and thus
little change in overall performance. Once - on 10 meters, the lowest
antenna was 20 db stronger than the top ... but the stack was just a bit
down from the stack.
And indeed - the overall heights matter just as much. My low antenna at
41'
was really too low for 20 ... and it is beginning to be too high on 10...
that stated I'd probably go with that one at 45' and then 37' spacing from
there putting the top antenna at 119'. Note however - its really not that
critical - just stack them 35' - 40' apart and around these heights...
I sold mine - I hope to be in South Carolina soon (this year - purchased
11
acres in Piedmont - just have to move and build a house)... and this time
I'm going with 2 stacks of 20m 5el and 15m 6 el on a rotating tower... the
pattern and gain is better overall.
The C31 stack played quite nicely on 20... and on 15... but I never really
felt it was doing what I'd expect on 10. I had it with a Force12 240N 2 el
40 meter at 130' and their Magnum 80 meter rotary dipole at 136'. And the
SWR on 15 was never great - I was one of those that had the 'notorious' 15
SWR problems that I could never get quite right.
As an aside I'd often ask people to guess which of the antennas/systems
worked best overall... most would say the 3 stack of C31's... but the best
antenna on that tower was the dipole on 80 at 136'... it was awesome. Why?
Because it was competing against mostly wire dipoles at 50' - 60'.
Gary, K9RX
I've been following the mail on this subject. I'm going to start my new
tower this summer. The base and anchors are already in. It's going to be a
137' rotating 55g tower with three F12 C31XR's stacked. I've been using
HFTA
to come up with the best compromise heights (compromise as I'm trying to
get
the best results on all 3 bands). Then it dawned on me. Should I be
worried
about stacking results or individual heights. Isn't the height of an
antenna
for a specific band at a certain time of day more of an advantage than the
combined stacking?, and of course it's still a compromise since we're
talking about tribanders. Don't get me wrong, I'm still going to try to
come
up with the best stacking distances for my location, but it seems to me
that
the most important feature of a stack is having 3 different heights to
choose from, isn't it? I sure wish the project was finished, it would have
come in handy this past weekend. Rich - N5ZC
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|