Hello Bob!
I have made a small linear with GI46 for HF (See www.hoeppe.name) . 500-550W
out are possible, but ONLY with proper cooling. I fully agree with you: A
weak airstream from the side is a bad advice! Those russian tubes have a
max. seal temperature of only 120 deg. C! I know there are many descriptions
in the internet showing that....but I would never do it!
Tom, DJ5RE
----- Original Message -----
From: "Robert Briggs" <vk3zl@bigpond.com>
To: <topband@contesting.com>
Sent: Tuesday, January 15, 2013 12:55 AM
Subject: Topband: GI-46B Revisited..
Gidday all..I have built around 25 aVHF amplifiers over the past three
years using the Russian triodes, GS-35 and 31B tubes as well as GI-6 and
7B tubes..All of these amplifiers are in daily service on 6 and 2 meters
and trouble free..
I have looked through all the information on the GI-46B tube and a few
things don't add up..A company in Europe uses these tubes in their
amplifier product's...I see many retro fits in UTube clips for TL922 and
Heathkit amplifiers replacing the 3-500Z and supposed power outputs of
1600 watts..
Just taking the TL922 conversion to GI-46B tubes as an example the tubes
are openly mounted with GI-7B coolers in place of the original 46B
cooler...The film clip shows the TL922 cooling fan retained blowing
against the tubes...I question how are they getting rid of all the heat
produced with such a pissy setup..I would have thought the tube should be
mounted in a box construction with a good blower and chimneys etc...
According to the Russian GI-46B specs the tube is only rated at 350 watts
anode dissipation...Most of these conversions will be running at close to
3kv and to produce 1600 watts output even at 50% efficiency a pair of
tubes will have to be dissipating a lot more than the tube anode rating..
Obviously the sketchy information for the GI-46B supplied on the Russian
spec sheet must be very conservative...
I am wondering if there are any members on this reflector have used the
GI-46B triode and what the real results are and also the cooling used..I
am about to do a 46B 6 and a 2 meter amplifier for a client using these
tubes..I am confident that with proper attention to the cooling etc that
the amplifiers will turn out ok..It has been suggested that the GI-46B is
a substitute for a 3CX800 tube..
Bob..VK3ZL..
_________________
Topband Reflector
_________________
Topband Reflector
|