This subject was debated at some length a few years ago. Some would say what
you send doesn't matter as long was the submitted log contains the correct
category and that you consistently send the same value. Others argue that
you should send the power you are running - again use the same value for all
the QSOs you have. As with most of these debates I don't think a conclusion
was reached in the earlier debate. Similar deal for All Asia where you send
your age or the check value in Sweepstakes.
Personally I just log what is sent to me. There are stations that might send
99 that sound like perhaps it should be 999 and others that send K that
sound more like 10. The station might be in null in the antenna pattern or
too close for the antenna height, or..... I used to try to work a friend
about 900 miles away on 40M and even with both of us running a KW we could
barely hear each other and sometimes not at all. One morning about 2AM
local time several years ago I was working stations on all continents from
the east coast with equal strength on 15M regardless of the direction I
pointed the yagi I was using. I am sure there are hundreds of similar
incidents happening all the time making it difficult to know whether a
station is telling the truth about the amount of power they are running.
If someone runs a KW and sends 99 that does not concern me. If that person
submits the log claiming that he/she was actually running 99W, then that is
a rule violation subject to any penalty enforcement allowed by the contest
sponsor. If the submitted log claims to be running a KW then it seems to be
non-issue to me.
73, Larry W6NWS
-----Original Message-----
From: Zack Widup
Sent: Thursday, February 27, 2014 8:51 AM
To: CQ Contest
Subject: Re: [CQ-Contest] Radio Laws of Propagation....Have they
beenre-invented?
Another thing is that I've received all sorts of oddball power levels
from people in the ARRL DX contest over the years. 999, 995, 763, 155,
37 ... I have often had a passing thought about how they measured it
and how accurate they were. But I also thought if anyone really cared
how close they were except for the contesting lawyers. I would think
that if they were within 5% or so, it wouldn't matter. And power out
of an amp varies across a band or from band to band. Someone may be
getting 500 watts out on 80 meters and start saying "500" in the
contest, but then on 10 meters they can only coax 350 out of the amp.
But they've already started using the number "500." You could say they
should have planned beforehand and checked the lowest power they would
get with everything cranked up and then adjust power down on the bands
where they got more. But if your short-term memory is as bad as mine
is getting, it would be easy to make this mistake. I don't even
remember what I did 10 minutes ago. :-)
If someone is reporting a power that is different enough to put them
in a different category in the contest, though, that's a different
story. Saying 100 watts and running 500 or a thousand would be a rules
violation. I guess that's the question at hand.
73, Zack W9SZ
On 2/27/14, Zack Widup <w9sz.zack@gmail.com> wrote:
Yes, good point, Paul. I was just indicating that he wasn't sending 42
in the contest.
73, Zack W9SZ
On 2/27/14, Paul O'Kane <pokane@ei5di.com> wrote:
I just checked my logs. I worked KP4KE on three bands. On all three
bands he sent me the power level of 100.
Hello Zack,
Whether he says he was running 42 watts or 100 watts makes
no difference. The charge is that he was louder than other
stations running 1500 watts.
The issue is - how much power was he actually running and,
if it was more than 150 watts, why did he not enter the HP
section?
compare, for Saturday February 15,
2014, the signal levels of KP4KE (42 watts) and NP2P (1.5KW) especially
on the low bands. Antennas on the low band are essentially the same.
KP4KE claims (3830 report) that has a dipole at 60' on 80 and so does
NP2P. (NP2P is 65 feet ABG. He claims on 40 meters a delta loop at 70'
and NP2P has a dipole at 65 feet. Now do you know how his claim of 42
watts to these antennas can outperform similar antennas into the
mainland locations against a station that is running (NP2P) 1500 watts?
73,
Paul EI5DI
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|