Excellent point. If everyone logs a silent 59 then it is valid!
Doug
"Those Island days are always on my mind,
Someday I'm going to leave it all behind."
-----Original Message-----
>> 1)Why ENN in cw contest is legal and silent omission of the default
59
> in
>> SSB contest is not?
>
> The rules call for a signal report. "ENN" is a valid signal report.
> "Silence" is not a signal report.
Hans, it is all conditional. If we all silently agree to consider
silence as
default 59 signal report then silence IS a signal report.
>> 2)If 59 found in the log of the sender as well as in the log of the
>> recipient at the time of cross checking what is the ground for
blaming
> the
>> sender in rules violation?
>
> If the sender didn't send a report and the recipient didn't receive a
> report, but the logs show a report was exchanged then both logs are
> falsified and ought be DQ'd.
I will wait and see how many logs of the WPX participants are going to
be
DQed just because you said they have to be DQed :)
73, Igor UA9CDC
> 73, de Hans, K0HB/W7
> "Just a boy and his radios"
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|