Good question, thanks. This was done a couple of decades ago, I admit. I
can't remember the part number, but they were rated at 2.5 amp and all the same
lot from a major reputable manufacturer.
I've heard the situation has improved as you say, but I have gotten mixed lots
of other parts in quantity purchases since then and the same problem may exist
in such a situation. The key is not so much how much they leak, but how much
the diodes vary in their reverse leakage or "equivalent resistance". I agree
it would be worthwhile to repeat the experiment with current parts, but still,
diodes and resistors are cheap.
Gene May
WB8WKU
Date: Wed, 25 Apr 2012 17:38:55 -0700
Subject: Re: [Amps] PIV requirements for identical, individual diodes
From: tomc@carneysugai.com
To: gene-may@hotmail.com
Hi Gene
Just curious, when did you do the test with the 200 1K diodes? My experience
is that current production, from the same lot, shows a lot less veriation in
leakage current.
73,
Tom K6EU
On Wed, Apr 25, 2012 at 5:23 PM, Gene May <gene-may@hotmail.com> wrote:
Reference the thread about this: The PIV across each diode in a bridge will be
the peak voltage of the transformer voltage. . . . . , I offer some words of
caution:
How the reverse voltage disributes across a chain of diodes is problematic in a
way that is similar to the way power supply output voltage distributes across a
chain of filter capacitors. One of the important functions that bleeder
resistors serve across such a string of capacitors is to equalize the voltage
drops. Just as electrolytic filter capacitors vary A LOT in how much they
"leak" current, meaning how much they vary as resistors across the output
voltage, rectifier diodes vary considerably in how much they leak when they are
reverse biased. Once when I had access to the instruments that I could do this
with, I got a batch of about 200 1 KV PIV diodes, reverse biased them to about
800V and measured the currents through them. The currents varied from several
microramperes to a mil or so, easily a ratio of 20:1 or more. This is the
reason that you see resistors of about 470K-ohms to about a megohm across a
chain of diodes -- to "swamp" the leakage and equalize the voltage dr
ops when they are reverse biased. I put about a megohm across each diode in a
chain or leg of diodes, and use enough diodes to give a total PIV of 5X the
output voltage. Nothing blows. I concede that I am conservative here, but
diodes and resistors are cheap.
Gene May
WB8WKU
_______________________________________________
Amps mailing list
Amps@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
_______________________________________________
Amps mailing list
Amps@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/amps
|