>
> On Jun 5, 2016, at 11:03 AM, Bill Turner <dezrat@outlook.com> wrote:
>
> I have been playing with DominoEX using fldigi in
> recent weeks. Not a lot of activity but QSOs are good and solid even
> with very low power.
Technically, DominoEX is probably my all-time favorite mode.
It has multiple speed selections, good error vs SNR, and the speed it can tune
to a station is the best I have seen. The latter is made possible because
DominoEX uses 17 incremental tones instead of 16 fixed codes; with good
software, that extra tone in the pattern allows the receiver to zero in to the
passband almost instantaneously.
In the presence of flutter, DominoEX 8 needs 16 dB (!) less transmit power to
do as well as 45.45 baud RTTY:
http://www.w7ay.net/site/Applications/cocoaModem/UsersManual/mfskManual/mfskManual/dominoex.html#characteristics
Here are some of my measurements for various ITU propagation models
http://www.w7ay.net/site/Technical/DominoEX/Measurements/itu.html
And for AWGN:
http://www.w7ay.net/site/Technical/DominoEX/Measurements/awgn.html
The tone coding that DominoEX uses makes it very good when there is a lot of
Doppler spreading (it never transmits a tone that is adjacent to a previous
tone), so spectrum smearing does not faze it). It can dig out a signal that is
so weak that I created a special tool in cocoaModem just so that you can “see”
the signal in the waterfall:
http://www.w7ay.net/site/Applications/cocoaModem/UsersManual/mfskManual/mfskManual/dominoex.html#weak
DominoEX' only weakness is the FEC mode. The FEC convolution code is too short
to help long fades and selective fades. But that is not the fault of Murray
ZL1BPU; someone else added the FEC to his original design, and that FEC became
the defacto standard. The FEC in MFSK16 is much better for HF propagation;
MFSK16 is yet another of Murray’s design, but unfortunately suffers from
difficulty to tune.
More recently, Murray took some of the better features from both MFSK16 and
DominoEX and created a slow keyboard-to-keyboard FSQ mode:
http://www.qsl.net/zl1bpu/MFSK/FSQweb.htm
(FSQ is also described in the September 2015 issue of QST.)
I doubt any mode out there can outshoot DominoEX and FSQ for NVIS type
propagation (tons of multipath). Unfortunately, there has never been much
DominoEX activity. FSQ may get better treatment, but probably not, what with
the rig merchants adding only PSK31 and RTTY decoders to their screens.
Oh yeah, I almost forgot, DominoEX has a very nifty feature: it does not
transmit an idle symbol when you pause typing, like with the Idle Varicode in
PSK31 and the diddle character in RTTY. Instead, it encodes a slow beacon
channel when you are not typing. You can include some canned message (your
callsign, your grid square, for example) and cocoaModem shows it as a
horizontally scrolling “Times Square ticker tape":
http://www.w7ay.net/site/Applications/cocoaModem/UsersManual/mfskManual/mfskManual/dominoex.html#beacon
73
Chen, W7AY
_______________________________________________
RTTY mailing list
RTTY@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/rtty
|