Chet - Thanks for the interesting note, which included this statement:
"Software Defined Radios next? It will be interesting to do the numbers when
the data is in for them."
Sherwood has numbers for several SDRs in his list:
< http://www.sherweng.com/table.html >
including the Flex 5000 and 3000 and the Perseus.
The close in third order intermodulation distortion (OMD) products turns out
not to be a very good figure of merit for receivers based on modern analog to
digital converters (ADC):
< http://www.sm5bsz.com/dynrange/qex/digital-imd.pdf >
< http://www.nitehawk.com/sm5bsz/pcdsp/dynmeas.htm >
as the third order IMD is pretty much independent of input signal level until
the ADC saturates, so the third order IMD is pretty much dependent only on the
dynamic range of the ADC used.
The Flex5000 and the Perseus have performance that is very close to the K3, and
depending on the K3 filters used, can exceed the K3 performance. Of great
interest, at least to me, is the third order dynamic range for the SDRs is
independent of signal separation, the performance at 2 kHz is essentially the
same as it is at 20 kHz.
While the K3 is a great radio, it is a bit deaf on 6M and to get reasonable
performance in a quiet location one needs to add a preamplifier. Elecraft
offers a very good one, I don't think that what that does to the third order
IMD has been measured yet. They also are about to start selling a 144 MHz
transverter that can be added to the K3. It is low power, 10W, and rather
expensive, but if it is anything like their external transverters, it should
have excellent performance.
The performance of the top 5 or 6 radios in Sherwood's list is excellent and I
doubt that anyone would be disappointed in their use as IF radios for good
transverters. Even the next 15 or so on the list are very good radios for
transverter use.
I have a friend who just got a Perseus. He proclaims it to be the best receiver
he has ever used,a nod that includes some very good radios. It is not cheap,
but if it is a harbinger of things to come in transceivers, our radios will
just keep getting better. - Duffey
--
KK6MC
James Duffey
Cedar Crest NM
_______________________________________________
VHFcontesting mailing list
VHFcontesting@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/vhfcontesting
|