"I read your posting with intense interest...from the perspective of 'why do
people participate in Amateur radio events'. Succinctly, it is for two
reasons: (A) Because it's fun and (B) there is a reward." - W2EV
...
Way back when I was studying to become a teacher, I learned a lot in the
required psychology classes. Of particular interest to me was "Maslow's
Heirarchy" from his 1943 work, "A Theory of Human Motivation."
In a nutshell, we are motivated to meet our more basic needs before moving to
the more advanced needs. First and foremost are SURVIVAL needs -- food,
clothing, etc. Once these are met, we move up the pyramid to SECURITY needs --
safety, health, income, insurance, etc.
ONLY after these are ensured are we able to proceed to the next level.
Here is where our hobby comes in. The next level is SOCIAL needs, such as
family, friends, and peers. We all need to be wanted and accepted. When these
needs are not met, people will naturally do whatever they find necessary to
achieve them. This is why kids who don't have a strong sense of family join
street gangs. Acceptance. This is why we form clubs and associations. This is
why we participate in operating activities.
Only after we feel we "belong", do we move on to the fourth level, ESTEEM
needs. We need to know that our peers hold us in esteem as a result of our
efforts. That's why we like to win contests and get pieces of paper. We need
some proof that we have "climbed the ladder". There is nothing wrong with that
need -- we are wired that way. Only after we have achieved justified
recognition are we able to move on to SELF-esteem. I'm talking about healthy
feelings of self-worth, backed up by proof. (Unless other people agree we are
deservedly worthwhile, anything we tell ourselves is a probably a lie and leads
to "egotism." This is where "peer pressure" can be positively used to keep us
all honest, and to deflate an unhealthy ego by knocking it down a peg.)
After all of this, and ONLY AFTER, can we reach the pinnacle of Maslow's
pyramid: SELF-ACTUALIZATION, a fancy term for being comfortable in our own
skin. The needs we have at this level are primarily leadership needs. Those who
reach this level are comfortably able to mentor others, to solve problems, to
create growth opportunities for others, to promote fairness, to judge fairly
and honestly, and to lead with kindness and wisdom.
...
What does all this have do with grid-circling rovers? Plenty. It's not hard to
perceive that they unfairly "rob" the rest of us "traditional" rovers of the
opportunity to meet our ESTEEM needs, no matter how hard we work. This is VERY
DISCOURAGING, as subconsciously we perceive it as other people "CHEATING" us by
taking a "SHORTCUT" to a goal that we have worked very hard for a long time to
acheive.
It demoralizes us.
This legitimate issue can only be settled by those few at the peak of Maslow's
pyramid -- the self-actualized leaders. In our case it is the VUCC and the
contest sponsors. They are in the leadership position, and hopefully they have
climbed the pyramid honestly and with integrity.
If that is the case (as I am sure it is), they will understand that the
recognition and reward of hard work and individual effort is important, and
worthy of protection and official support. The rules, as they stand, are
broken. They allow a crafty few to get rewards for little effort (except for
spending money, and for road rallying), while others who put forth considerable
effort to "work as many stations in as many grid squares as possible" are
effectively shut out from achieving any well-deserved recognition for their
efforts and sacrifices.
The only way to fix it is to explicitly prohibit grid-circling in limited rover
and "classic" rover categories.
If allowed to continue, the traditional rovers will naturally find another way
to achieve their esteem needs. In my case, I've been welcomed with open arms as
an operator at a world-class multi-op station (W3SO). I am honored, and have
done my best to keep up the rate and to help out however I can.
That fulfills some of my esteem and self-actualization needs. I still prefer to
rove and still yearn to explore and operate from exotic mountaintops, and still
have antennas to design and experiment with, but those self-actualizing goals
will have to wait until I can put forth an honest effort on a level playing
field.
THE ONLY WAY TO FIX IT IS TO EXPLICITLY PROHIBIT GRID-CIRCLING IN LIMITED ROVER
AND "CLASSIC" ROVER CATEGORIES.
73 de Joe, W3BC
_______________________________________________
VHFcontesting mailing list
VHFcontesting@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/vhfcontesting
|