I own the following analyzers
1) N2PK,
2) DG8SAQ (SDR-Kits)
3) FA-VA5
4) Rig Expert AA-55 Zoom
5) EU1KY
Having grown up in a lab using a waveguide directional coupler, BWO sweeper,
diode detector and oscilloscope with a grease pencil line for "calibration
memory" to make SWR measurements, I'm a pushover for these marvelous instruments
that can be held in the palm of my hand and that I can afford.
That said, the first two on this list, while being the most accurate, are not
handheld.
The FA-VA5 is nice, can be read in sunlight, but suffers, IMHO, by a cumbersome
interface. Running something this capable with three push buttons is a
stretch. This can also be used as a "front-end" to the DG8SAQ VNWA software
which is extremely powerful, remarkably free and can be run on a Windows tablet
in the field.
The AA-55 Zoom is good, although difficult to read in sunlight and has some
glitches if you want to import data to a computer. It likes to add one bogus
data point to the end of a file. When I first got mine and had issues, the
support was very good. As I found more nits to pick, the situation changed.
The also have the Rig Expert "AntScope" program to operate and manipulate data.
The older version of this is actually better. The choice of screen colors in
the later version are impossible for me to read. One of those nits that remains
unresolved.
The EU1KY is a kit and runs open source firmware, that is in constant
development by a number of guys. I'm using some by DH1AKF. There are occasional
lockups but generally it's fine. It's in a rugged, but slightly clunky
enclosure and uses a full color touch screen. This washes out in sunlight but
there is a "fat lines-daylight" mode that works okay. See:
https://bitbucket.org/kuchura/eu1ky_aa_v3/wiki/Home Interestingly enough this
also interfaces to the Rig Expert AntScope software.
IMHO, the FA-VA5 offers the best bang for the buck. My second choice for field
work would be the AA-55.
Wes N7WS
On 6/6/2019 10:56 AM, David Gilbert wrote:
I don't own either, but from every published comparison I've ever seen (with
actual data) the Rig Expert is far superior to the MFJ.
I do own the SDR-Kits FA-VA5, though, and it is an inexpensive option (less
than $200 USD) in a small size (roughly 3 inches wide by 5 inches tall by 1
inch thick) that works up to 600 MHz with really good accuracy over a wide
impedance range due to its built in calibration procedure. It can be used
alone, or in conjunction with a laptop computer via its built in USP port, and
there is free software available that will even make it work like a TDR for
checking cable lengths or finding impedance discontinuities. It comes in kit
form, but it is quite easy to build. All of the surface mount parts are
already in place ... you only have to solder a few thru hole parts before
mounting everything in the included case. It uses two AA alkaline batteries
for a claimed 40 hours usage.
https://www.sdr-kits.net/VA5_Page
The only downside is the waiting list due to the high demand for it, but it
beats my old AEA HF-CIA hands down.
73,
Dave AB7E
On 6/6/2019 9:31 AM, Garry via TowerTalk wrote:
Good Day,
I am interesting in a graphical antenna analyzer and considering the Rig
Expert AA-30/54 or MFJ-226. If anyone has any experience with these, I would
appreciate any comments.
Thanks & 73,Garry - K4OR
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|