I bought a Voyager for 160 m. Before I put it up, some people I trusted
advised me to put up an inverted L instead. That I did, and sold the
Voyager to a friend, new in box for about 1/2 what I paid so I think he got
a pretty good deal. I've heard one Voyager on 160 and the signal was
lousy. OTOH the inverted L with 101 radials (so far) is working quite well
considering its height and location (only 25' up 180 deg., then another 25'
at 135 deg. and the rest horiz 90 deg.).
The Gap "radials" are extensions of the bottom half of a vert. off center
fed (i.e. asymetric) dipole that has a feedpoint matched to ~50 ohms with
coax stubs, caps, and linear loading. Since the extensions are very close
to the earth's surface in terms of wavelength on 160 m. I think there is a
lot of rf lost in coupling from them to earth. If you were able to elevate
the whole thing quite a bit so the 3 extenstions were around 30 feet away
from ground surface that loss might be lowered. The top part above the
insulator is significantly small at 1.9 mhz and therefore not very efficient
on 160 even with the top loading. You have to ask yourself--if this were a
wonderful medium wave design, broadcasters would be using something similar
and saving $$$ on paint and aircraft obstruction lamps.
If you want to just have a taste of 160 it may be okay as it seems to work
pretty well on 80 and 40. If you want a good antenna on 160 I'd advise you
to go with something at least 60 feet (~45 degrees) tall, base fed on an
insulator over a lot of radials. You can run a wire off the top (inv. L),
or ground the vertical with a metal arm at the top sticking out to hold a
wire hanging down to your feedpoint to make a folded 1/4 w. monopole (what
hams call shunt feeding which I think is a confusing and nondescriptive
term). If you don't care about the swr, and want to run qro, use robust
feed such as 213 or 1/2 inch heliax and tune in the shack. If you want to
be picky, put a matching network at the feedpoint. hope this helps you or
others in ur position decide what to do.
73,
rob / k5uj
_________________________________________________________________
Express yourself instantly with MSN Messenger! Download today - it's FREE!
http://messenger.msn.click-url.com/go/onm00200471ave/direct/01/
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|