In a message dated 11/5/01 8:58:02 AM Eastern Standard Time, K7GCO@aol.com
writes:
> Yuri: I duplicated your figure A=.026167978 WL by creating 2 "right
> triangles" with a line at 3 degrees bisecting the line bewteen the .25 WL
> tips (for further clarification). Without a right triangle the sine
factor
> is not correct. Yuri I didn't know you were good on math also. hi
>
> Actually most all this radial math nonsence goes away with 1/2 wave
> verticals. With the finances of the average DXer today, I cannot see why
> any
> DXer screws around with 1/4 waves. A 1/2 wave is already resonant and
> doesn't need any more help in that department. I've had great success
with
> 1/2 waves with just a ground rod to cool the coax shield feeding an L
> network. How much E-field loss is there at the base without any radials?
> I'm not sure. The higher the base of a 1/2 wave this problem reduces
itself.
>
> I will run a comparison with a side by side 1/2 waves--one with a ground
> rod
> and one over a good radial system. WWVH has some radials out a ways. I
> don't think they have to be a 1/4 wave although it sure can't hurt.
>
> Has anyone else any 1/2 wave vertical experience? K7GCO
Well,
"my" formula is accurate and useful down to 1 radial(s) and cheap (free),
practical from 3 and up and it is correct (check it out -:) no need for right
angle triangles.
On the subject of half wave verticals, one can not overlook quality of ground
required for effective performance at low angles. Even if the vertical
(whatever) needs no radials, its performance is affected by the quality of
ground. So if over land, if you put down the ground screen under the
radialless vertical antenna, you will gain big jump in performance. I saw
this last WW SSB contest weekend when I setup my vertical "artillery" - 4
square and 3 el dual pol quad here behind the house, instead of the beach
front at Cape Hatteras, they sucked!!
When I tried to have 4 square made out of half wave vertical dipoles
(~110ohm) using Comtek phasing unit on 10 m, there was a problem, had to
"degrade" it to 1/4 waves with single radials, and it works as it supposed
to.
73 Yuri
visit 2001 Radiofest East Nov 10 at Glen Spey, NY
see www.verkhovyna.com and click on Radiofest
List Sponsored by AN Wireless: AN Wireless handles Rohn tower systems,
Trylon Titan towers, coax, hardline and more. Also check out our self
supporting towers up to 100 feet for under $1500!! http://www.anwireless.com
-----
FAQ on WWW: http://www.contesting.com/FAQ/towertalk
Submissions: towertalk@contesting.com
Administrative requests: towertalk-REQUEST@contesting.com
Problems: owner-towertalk@contesting.com
|