I didn't see any post where it was claimed the antennas would not radiate,
which I guess would me also mean "work".
The truth is you have to have some radiation from the feeder or an end-fed
wire antenna in Zepp (or J-pole) configuration. This is what often causes RF
in the shack with such setups.
That is minimized with a perfect floating tuner with very high common mode
impedance and a 1/4 wl feedlineand a 1/2 wl long antenna. (Moving a balun to
the input of a tuner does NOT help the balun do a better job, contarary to
popular false claims it does.) None of this means the antenna won't work, it
just is a mistake to think the second feedline wire makes the system ground
independent.
73 Tom
_______________________________________________
Topband mailing list
Topband@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/topband
|