Although it obviously radiates Bill, I question the efficiency of a #12
wire 4' away from a large tower cross section.
Do you have anything to show that this is a correct d1/d2 ratio and
spacing? It just does not seem proper IMO and I would think that it
could be improved.
An accurate way to grid dip a tower was explained in my 12/86 CQ article.
Simply drop a #12 or so wire from the very top of the tower and couple
loosely to the gdo at the base via a one turn loop and the antenna
appears as a folded unipole. This required a minimum of 4 radials at the
tower to function properly for me. .
Most GDO's do not cover below 2MHz. I used a Millen 90651-A tube gdo with
the 46702 coil which covers 925 to 2000kHz. The Measurements Corp Model
59 with the 59LF head and coils is another choice. I am not aware of any
SS GDO that includes that low a frequency coverage.
The 100' tower at the old QTH with the 10/15/20 monobanders reasonated at
1425 KHz. A 140' tower with a 4el 40 and 4el 10/15 above that
reasonated at 1290KHz. Altho both matched and worked well individually,
all attempts to phase them were not successful. Spacing was a tight 70'.
When I moved here I followed Bill's Colorado example and just hung a 1/4
wave wire from the top guy of a 160' tower and used elevated radials. It
worked so well I added a second wire and phased them. The tops are only
about 50' apart and the bases are 135' . Directivity with a simple ON4UN
78 degree coax phasing line is over 15dB and often 25dB, depending on
arrival angle. Since I am on a hill with solid rock just below the grass
I am amazed it works so well....all the textbooks say do not use a
vertical on a hill at 160M and BC frequencies.
I also have an inverted V at 160' which is superior out to 1500-2000
miles but the vertical blows it away on long haul including greyline
either East or West.
All of the responses here have been very informative; keep them coming.
73....Carl KM1H
--
FAQ on WWW: http://www.contesting.com/topband.html
Submissions: topband@contesting.com
Administrative requests: topband-REQUEST@contesting.com
Problems: owner-topband@contesting.com
|