One additional point regarding loss is the type of dielectric being used.
The true open wire line will have less matched loss per given unit and
frequency than the window type line as long as the spacing between the
conductors is a very small fraction of the wavelength..
Based on the Transmission Line Calculator by N6BV:
For 600 ohm open wire line to a load of 50 ohms: 100 ft at 30 MHz will have
a 10.49:1 SWR at the input and a 12.0:1 SWR at the load. Total loss would
be 0.584 dB {line loss + SWR loss} Matched line loss is 0.105 dB.
For 450 ohm window line to a load of 50 ohms: 100 ft at 30 MHz will have a
7.11:1 SWR at the input and a 8.10:1 SWR at the load. Total loss would be
0.574 dB {line loss + SWR loss} Matched line loss is 0.152 dB
Although the 600 ohm line does have lower matched loss than the 450 ohm
line, due to a closer match, otherwise somewhat lower SWR, the added loss of
the lower SWR value will make for less overall loss.
This seems to confirm what Steve says regarding using 450 ohm line. Using
the same calculations for 450 ohm window line, except using a load of 40
ohms the total feedline loss would be 0.702 Db. SWR at the input would be
8.61:1 and at the load the SWR would be 10.12:1. Then for a load of 4000
ohms the total feedline loss would be 0.716 dB with the SWR at the input
being 8.44:1 and the SWR at the load would be 9.88:1
And I agree with Jims earlier comments, using a balanced feedline does not
necessarily make for a balanced antenna system. Jim listed other factors
that can cause a system to be somewhat unbalanced.
73
Bob, K4TAX
----- Original Message -----
From: "Steve Hunt" <steve@karinya.net>
To: "Discussion of Ten-Tec Equipment" <tentec@contesting.com>
Sent: Wednesday, October 17, 2012 3:03 AM
Subject: Re: [TenTec] Model 238C Tuner Questions
Jim,
Those are important points of clarification that you raise!! I frequently
hear folk commending ladderline-feed for a multiband doublet on the basis
that "ladderline handles high SWR much better than coax" - that tells me
there is still much misunderstanding about the fundamental causes of loss
in HF transmission lines.
I would add just one thought to what you've explained:
A typical multiband doublet might exhibit feedpoint impedances anywhere
from 40 Ohms to 4000 Ohms depending on the band. To minimise SWR
excursions across the bands we would want to choose a transmission line
characteristic impedance that is the geometric mean of those figures:
Zo=SQRT(40*4000)=400Ohms. Choosing a commercial ladderline would limit the
SWR to around 10:1 at worst; whereas using 50Ohm coax we would have 1.25:1
at one extreme and 80:1 at the other.
So, not only does the high impedance line benefit from flowing lower
current for a given power level, it can also minimise the worst-case SWR
experienced.
73,
Steve G3TXQ
On 17/10/2012 01:57, Jim Brown wrote:
On 10/16/2012 5:32 PM, Robert Mcgraw wrote:
The feed impedance on my 160M 1/2 wave wire is about 38 ohms as I
recall.
Some clarifications. First, feedline loss is directly related to
feedline current and conductor resistance, and is determined both by the
feedline impedance and the SWR. What gives open wire line it's low loss
characteristic is it's IMPEDANCE, NOT the fact that it is balanced. Loss
is lower in high Z line because for a given power level and the same
conductor size, because the current is lower.
_______________________________________________
TenTec mailing list
TenTec@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/tentec
_______________________________________________
TenTec mailing list
TenTec@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/tentec
|