ORIGINAL MESSAGE:
At 08:04 PM 5/22/2006, Rick Mintz wrote:
>Before I do the mod, a question for those that have a 250 Hz
>filter.... Have you found this to be to narrow for RTTY contesting?
>Any other comments?
*********** REPLY SEPARATOR ***********
It depends on the steepness of the filter's skirts, but here's a
quick check you can do, assuming you are running MMTTY with the
crossed ellipses or have a crossed-ellipses scope monitor.
1. Using the 250 Hz filter, tune in a weak station to where the
ellipses are crossed at the normal 90 degrees.
2. Note the amplitude of each ellipse.
3. Slowly tune off the correct point and see if either ellipse
increases in amplitude. Tune in both directions, watching both ellipses.
4. If the filter is too narrow, one or both of the ellipses will
increase in amplitude when mis-tuned. This tells you that with normal
tuning, one or both of the received frequencies is partly outside the
bandpass of the receiver.
5. If the amplitude of each ellipse stays the same or decreases, your
bandwidth is ok.
It is important that you do this with a relatively weak signal so the
AGC of your receiver and the AGC of MMTTY or your TNC does not
compensate for the reduced signal outside the bandpass, if any.
Theoretically, a 250 Hz filter with really steep skirts is too narrow
for 170 Hz shift, but I have used several receivers with a more or
less "normal" 250-270 Hz filter and observed no ill effects. The
theoretical ideal, according to the experts, is between 300-350 Hz,
given a "perfect" filter. I suspect you'll find your filter is quite ok.
The effect of a too-narrow filter is to "round off" the corners of
what should be a perfect square wave being fed to the RTTY
demodulator. Some rounding is tolerable, but too much gives a flat
portion of the top or bottom that is too short (both in time and
amplitude) to demodulate properly. Strong signals will have enough
amplitude to compensate for reduced amplitude on the filter skirts,
but weak signals will be a problem.
Bill, W6WRT
_______________________________________________
RTTY mailing list
RTTY@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/rtty
|