Hey John,
No stones being thrown here. And, in fact, I made mistakes myself.
Indeed, I was given a recording of some of them.
We just had a long thread about identifying --- this was written in context
to that, as was meant to re-enforce how important it is sending/affirming
your call.
73, Gerry W1VE
On Mon, Feb 10, 2014 at 8:24 AM, <john@kk9a.com> wrote:
> What is the purpose of publicly listing everyone that miscopied your
> callsign? This is a contest where a station has a limited time to put as
> many stations in their log as possible. While we all try an copy as
> accurately as possible, there are risks that you have to take by not
> confirming every bit of information when running at a high rate of speed.
> On CW dits just sometimes disappear and I am sure that many of these
> operators did not get your call wrong from a bad packet spot. For example,
> 8P5A (who was not assisted) made over 7,000 QSO's and he made a mistake
> copying W1VE. Tom is a fantastic operator who just missed the dit, what
> is the big deal?
>
> John KK9A
>
>
>
> To: CQ-Contest <cq-contest@contesting.com>
> From: Gerry Hull <gerry@yccc.org>
> Date: Sat, 8 Feb 2014 08:20:29 -0500
>
> I just read my LCR review for CQWW CW. I was one of those who always sent
> my call every time.
> I took time out of pileups to correct the caller when they sent my call
> wrong.
>
> Unfortunately, My friend Dennis, W1UE, has a call only one dit away from
> mine. The results are as follows:
>
> ************* Stations Copying W1VE Incorrectly **************
>
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 0021 LA6GX 14 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 0028 CO2IR 8 W1VEN 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 0031 F5UL 14 W1UE 5
> 7018 CW 2013-11-23 0046 DL9NCR 14 W1UE 5
> 14019 CW 2013-11-23 0052 JT5DX 23 K1VE 5
> 14030 CW 2013-11-23 0100 TO7A 8 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 0103 OM3RP 15 W1UE 5
> 14054 CW 2013-11-23 0103 8P5A 8 W1UE 5
> 3500 CW 2013-11-23 0147 YV5KG 9 W1UE 5
> 7016 CW 2013-11-23 0206 OM7OM 15 W1UE 5
> 3508 CW 2013-11-23 0304 R5DT 16 W1UE 5
> 7063 CW 2013-11-23 0311 PJ4Q 9 NW1VE 5
> 3508 CW 2013-11-23 0340 VE3TW 4 W1UE 5
> 3508 CW 2013-11-23 0356 K5GDX 4 W1VT 5
> 3508 CW 2013-11-23 0407 FG8NY 8 W1UE 5
> 7098 CW 2013-11-23 0426 PR7AB 11 W1UE 5
> 7005 CW 2013-11-23 0443 EA5RS 14 W9VE 5
> 7065 CW 2013-11-23 0444 OK7AW 15 W1UE 5
> 7049 CW 2013-11-23 0544 HB9CIC 14 W1UE 5
> 3534 CW 2013-11-23 0612 VP5CW 8 W1UE 5
> 7009 CW 2013-11-23 0646 OK1WMJ 15 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 0654 DJ2XC 14 W1FE 5
> 7009 CW 2013-11-23 0655 RA3Y 16 W1HE 5
> 7010 CW 2013-11-23 0656 SM5C 14 W1UE 5
> 7009 CW 2013-11-23 0704 DK1KC 14 W1UE 5
> 7032 CW 2013-11-23 0707 DA0I 14 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 0802 OM7AG 15 W1UE 5
> 7010 CW 2013-11-23 0810 OK2SAR 15 W1UE 5
> 14053 CW 2013-11-23 1026 R3FC 16 W2VE 5
> 14023 CW 2013-11-23 1101 R3FX 16 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 1113 DL1RTS 14 W1UE 5
> 14024 CW 2013-11-23 1129 S51RJ 15 W1UE 5
> 21013 CW 2013-11-23 1138 PA0CT 14 W1UE 5
> 28081 CW 2013-11-23 1209 ZS6TQ 38 W1UE 5
> 21018 CW 2013-11-23 1224 ON7SS 14 W1UE 5
> 21018 CW 2013-11-23 1227 HB9CIC 14 W1UE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-23 1234 G3R 14 W1UE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-23 1242 OK1AOU 15 W1UE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-23 1245 UT7LW 16 W14VE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1257 PA0SKP 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1258 RN6AJ 16 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1315 LA2MOA 14 W1UE 5
> 28023 CW 2013-11-23 1335 DL7UIO 14 W1UE 5
> 28023 CW 2013-11-23 1339 G3IZD 14 W1UE 5
> 28010 CW 2013-11-23 1339 DL3WKG 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1344 SM5Q 14 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1347 SM5COP 14 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1350 ON9CC 14 W1UE 5
> 28023 CW 2013-11-23 1357 UT7EL 16 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1408 EA3NO 14 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1408 PG2AA 14 W1UE 5
> 28023 CW 2013-11-23 1413 DK3YD 14 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1413 S51NM 15 W2VE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1417 DL8UKE 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1423 EA5ARC 14 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1430 OK1RIG 15 W1UE 5
> 28023 CW 2013-11-23 1432 R7AM 16 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1446 OK2SAR 15 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1449 GW4J 14 W1UE 5
> 28024 CW 2013-11-23 1452 R3LC 16 W1UE 5
> 28023 CW 2013-11-23 1453 9A3B 15 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1459 G3R 14 W1UE 5
> 28023 CW 2013-11-23 1513 DJ6UP 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1519 DL7UMK 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1529 HB9AZZ 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1530 HB9TXE 14 W2VE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-23 1531 OK1MDK 15 W1UE 5
> 21017 CW 2013-11-23 1622 HB9DDE 14 W1UE 5
> 21017 CW 2013-11-23 1625 YL3GX 15 W1UE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-23 1630 XE2FGC 6 W1UE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-23 1644 DM5Z 14 W1HE 5
> 21025 CW 2013-11-23 1710 LA9WDA 14 N1VE 5
> 14007 CW 2013-11-23 1713 SV9DJO 20 W2VE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 1845 HA1SN 15 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 1851 LY2AX 15 W1UE 5
> 14030 CW 2013-11-23 1851 K1TH 5 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 1904 DK1YY 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 1904 DL9CW 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 1910 SP5GDY 15 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 1929 SP6NIC 15 W1UE 5
> 14030 CW 2013-11-23 2006 DK5JM 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 2008 DJ6BS 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 2009 IT9PPG 15 W1UE 5
> 14031 CW 2013-11-23 2018 HB9DDE 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-23 2019 IZ2CEF 15 K1VE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2107 LA7DHA 14 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2118 DL7UMK 14 W1UE 5
> 7006 CW 2013-11-23 2121 YR1A 20 W1UE 5
> 7006 CW 2013-11-23 2126 DK5JM 14 W1UE 5
> 7006 CW 2013-11-23 2126 SM5COP 14 W1UE 5
> 7006 CW 2013-11-23 2129 PA0SKP 14 W1UE 5
> 7006 CW 2013-11-23 2142 DK3WJ 14 W1UE 5
> 7006 CW 2013-11-23 2142 G3SVL 14 W1UE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-23 2156 JF0EBM 25 W1UE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-23 2207 PV8ADI 11 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2223 DL2RUG 14 W1UE 5
> 7005 CW 2013-11-23 2227 G3P 14 W1UE 5
> 7005 CW 2013-11-23 2228 OK1LO 15 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2237 DF6RI 14 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2237 DJ9CN 14 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2254 OK2SGW 15 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2258 DL6MIG 14 W1UE 5
> 7005 CW 2013-11-23 2306 SP4JCQ 15 EW1VE 16
> 7005 CW 2013-11-23 2315 PA0SKP 14 W1FE 5
> 7025 CW 2013-11-23 2320 GW3NAS 14 W2VE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-23 2324 SQ3A 15 W1UE 5
> 7005 CW 2013-11-23 2327 DL3RHN 14 W1UE 5
> 7005 CW 2013-11-23 2335 9A3B 15 W1UE 5
> 14028 CW 2013-11-24 0031 BY1CW 24 W2VE 5
> 14028 CW 2013-11-24 0033 RA0QQ 19 W1UE 5
> 3500 CW 2013-11-24 0125 DL4FAP 14 W1UE 5
> 14052 CW 2013-11-24 0214 JE7JDL 25 W1UE 5
> 7027 CW 2013-11-24 0329 TM6M 14 W1UE 5
> 7031 CW 2013-11-24 0331 ZW8T 11 W1UE 5
> 3516 CW 2013-11-24 0429 OH5Z 15 W1KE 5
> 3500 CW 2013-11-24 0525 F5NKX 14 W1UE 5
> 3500 CW 2013-11-24 0535 F5CT 14 W1UE 5
> 3500 CW 2013-11-24 0541 DL7UMK 14 W1UE 5
> 3531 CW 2013-11-24 0653 HC1WDT 10 W1UE 5
> 7041 CW 2013-11-24 0736 PA3EMN 14 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-24 0901 JA1JKG 25 W1EE 5
> 7031 CW 2013-11-24 1027 JF1SQC 25 W1WE 5
> 14034 CW 2013-11-24 1128 OU2W 14 W1HE 5
> 21007 CW 2013-11-24 1220 LZ1NT 20 W1UE 5
> 21006 CW 2013-11-24 1222 HA30S 15 W1UE 5
> 21005 CW 2013-11-24 1247 DL8MBS 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1310 OE2UKL 15 W1UE 5
> 28014 CW 2013-11-24 1318 HA3HX 15 W1UE 5
> 28015 CW 2013-11-24 1319 YL2AG 15 W1FE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1320 ES2TT 15 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1323 YU7KM 15 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1324 VU2CDP 22 W1UE 5
> 28014 CW 2013-11-24 1324 OK1XC 15 W2VE 5
> 28015 CW 2013-11-24 1327 SM4DQE 14 W1UE 5
> 28015 CW 2013-11-24 1336 SB0A 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1355 I1EIS 15 W1FE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1356 OK1GS 15 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1413 R6CW 16 W2VE 5
> 28015 CW 2013-11-24 1425 OM4EX 15 W1UE 5
> 28014 CW 2013-11-24 1435 YO2IS 20 W1UE 5
> 21048 CW 2013-11-24 1445 GM4X 14 W1UE 5
> 21047 CW 2013-11-24 1458 UT7NI 16 W1UE 5
> 28011 CW 2013-11-24 1520 EI8JX 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1524 I1EIS 15 W1UE 5
> 28011 CW 2013-11-24 1527 EA3KN 14 W1VT 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1530 S58RU 15 W2VE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1533 TM5T 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1536 EU3AA 16 W1UE 5
> 28025 CW 2013-11-24 1545 OK2EC 15 W1JE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1546 OZ4KG 14 W1UE 5
> 28011 CW 2013-11-24 1613 VE6SQ 4 W1UE 5
> 21060 CW 2013-11-24 1620 SV9DJO 20 W1UE 5
> 28011 CW 2013-11-24 1620 M0TDW 14 W1UE 5
> 28000 CW 2013-11-24 1635 DK1YY 14 W1UE 5
> 28010 CW 2013-11-24 1640 LA3LJ 14 K1VE 5
> 21000 CW 2013-11-24 1714 TM5CD 14 W1FE 5
> 28114 CW 2013-11-24 1812 PY2MTV 11 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-24 1845 EI7CC 14 W1UE 5
> 14028 CW 2013-11-24 1846 DF3AX 14 W1UE 5
> 14085 CW 2013-11-24 1912 PA5KT 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-24 1928 DL0NG 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1929 SK3W 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1931 R1CT 16 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1931 G4MUL 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1932 EA5DFV 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1932 OL1C 15 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1933 DL5NEN 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1934 G0LHZ 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1935 F6FDR 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-24 1935 ON4TO 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1937 EA1FA 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1937 EA7OT 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1938 DL4ZA 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-24 1939 DF6RI 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1943 PA0LOU 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-24 1950 I2JIN 15 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1952 DK1CO 14 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 1954 HB9CA 14 W1UE 5
> 14000 CW 2013-11-24 1959 LY2BKT 15 W1UE 5
> 14018 CW 2013-11-24 2005 GI0RQK 14 W1UE 5
> 14025 CW 2013-11-24 2022 TM2Y 14 W1UE 5
> 14058 CW 2013-11-24 2032 PA3ACA 14 W1UE 5
> 14058 CW 2013-11-24 2034 KB7H 3 W1UE 5
> 14058 CW 2013-11-24 2034 VE2LX 5 W1VG 5
> 1827 CW 2013-11-24 2204 MW0EDX 14 W1UE 5
> 7000 CW 2013-11-24 2239 IK3DVY 15 W2VE 5
> 7026 CW 2013-11-24 2244 DL4ZA 14 W1UE 5
> 7004 CW 2013-11-24 2255 ES9C 15 W1VT 5
> 3516 CW 2013-11-24 2341 LY4A 15 W1UE 5
>
>
> My bet is that many of these people were convinced by a bad packet
> spot that I was W1UE, even thought I sent my call EVERY time. See the
> bunch from 1912z - 1959? That had to be a bad spot.
>
> So, people, you have to copy the on-the-air CW! And, despite the
> controversy, you have to send your call often.
>
>
> 73, Gerry W1VE -- see ya in ARRL DX CW next weekend.
>
> _______________________________________________
> CQ-Contest mailing list
> CQ-Contest@contesting.com
> http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
>
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|