de N4ZR:
So long as we decide where to draw the lines, and the vast majority of
participants respect the rules (particularly those who wish to have any
respect themselves), none of this needs to happen.
Saiboat racing is alive and well, and nobody feels the need for gas turbine
engines on them.
Pete,
with all respect - many discussions here have shown the difference between
sailboat racing or marathon running and ham contesting. "We have to embrace
new technology as we are a tech hobby and it helps to gain new blood - or do
we still operate with spark transmitters and straight keys?" Argument
solved, end of discussion, development accepted.
Of course most of the developments were evolutionary steps: from straight
key to electronic keyer to memory keyer to computer generated CW. As they
still require human action (even if fewer and fewer) few of them were as
fundamental as i.e. skimmer, which threw the human more or less completely
out of finding stations via S&P (we only HOPE that people verify calls by
ear - they could also safely assume that the few busts are not worth the
time listening even if they were able to).
So for me it seems really difficult to see a generally accepted core of our
activity like in running. Reading discussions about Echolink etc. you find
even very vocal people saying: As long as at least a minimal part is
wireless it is real amateur radio. So where would you draw a line between
widely automatted RTTY-/CW-contesting and robot-contesting to come? Or could
it not be sold as "Only an extension of existing ESM- and
RTTY-grabbing-logic"? The decoded combination "...Callsign test" triggers
grab and call without human command, with following detected exchange
triggering own exchange.
Will the associated dealing with software-tweaking not help to gain new
blood not yet gained for ham radio? Why suddenly stop on the path of
engineering more convenience?
Besides all pro and con - do we really know about a line and do enough
contesters want to draw a line?
Best 73, Chris (DL8MBS)
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|