Bill, I fully agree with the K.I.S.S. principle but don't think we all know the
reasons behind the
current LotW certification process. I can only imagine how much gripping and
complaining ARRL would
have gotten if they had made it any less secure.
As for the "dumbing down", well, yes, to some the LotW certification and
submission process may be a
pain, intimidating or just plain aggravating. But, if you follow the
instructions, everything will
work..easily. I cannot help but believe that hams, who have gone to the effort
to learn theory,
code, pass the exam and build a station would be thwarted by this. I can only
surmise that it simply
boils down to one thing....failure (refusal?) to follow instructions.
Yes, I read UA9CDC's message and also refer to the response from Art RX9TX. I
can confirm what Art
says...I have a LotW QSL from UA9CDC. :))
73, Ted W4NZ
Antennas on Tennessee - September 11 - The Tennessee QSO party
www.k4ro.net/tcg/tqp/tqp05_rules.html
|-----Original Message-----
|From: Bill Turner [mailto:dezrat1242@ispwest.com]
|Sent: Monday, July 25, 2005 12:17 PM
|To: Ted Bryant; cq-contest@contesting.com
|Subject: Re: [CQ-Contest] L.O.T.W.
|
|
|At 08:01 PM 7/24/2005, Ted Bryant wrote:
|>Normally I stay out of these topics but there is an irony here that I just
|>cannot pass up. On
|>another reflector there is a huge discussion raging about the "dumbing
|>down" of our hobby. Here, I
|>find people moaning and groaning about the "complexity" of setting up an
|>LotW account. Sheesh!!
|
|_________________________________________________
|
|Point taken, Ted. I have nothing against complexity when it is needed, but
|LoTW is an example of overkill. We all have only so much energy to spend so
|how about simplifying things where possible? Let's spend that extra time
|and energy chasing DX or contesting!
|
|It has nothing to do with 'dumbing down', in fact just the opposite. A
|programmer - a GOOD programmer - will spend extra time and effort to make
|his product as user friendly as possible while still accomplishing his goals.
|
|Did you read the email from UA9CDC? There are a lot of stations who will
|not use LoTW because of it's complexity. Those of us who do use it are
|missing out on QSLs because of it.
|
|Bill, W6WRT
|
_______________________________________________
CQ-Contest mailing list
CQ-Contest@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/cq-contest
|