I agree that VUCC is difficult for a rover to earn, but especially on
the microwave bands, certainly not impossible. Working five grids on 10
GHz is certainly possible for a rover during a contest.
I'd love to see a similar award created for rovers, or perhaps an
adaptation to the VUCC Award to encourage rovers.
73,
Les N1LF
On 6/19/2013 2:52 PM, David DeVos wrote:
The VUCC is one big dis-incentive to roving and may be one reason why some have
stopped roving because none of a rover's contacts count towards the award.
Although CSVHF has attempted to do something about this with the VUCC/R award,
that award does not appeal to me. Operating from 100 different grids to win
the VUCC/R award doesn't really line up with the normal rover intense work of
operating a VHF contest in my opinion. So- None of the contacts I make while
roving count for any ARRL award. Plus, I've got to keep those contacts
segregated from my home station contacts in a separate log.
Regardless, I still enjoy roving my 10 bands, and helping others win the VUCC.
It's a triple challenge 1- technical trying to keep everything running, 2-
physical, trying to to keep energy up and keep operating, and 3- strategic,
trying to figure out the best way to travel and the best places to operate.
KF8QL/R
David DeVos
On Jun 19, 2013, at 10:23 AM, Les Rayburn <les@highnoonfilm.com> wrote:
Several amateurs have written to tell me that they are reaching out to their
ARRL Division Directors and endorsing the idea of a Five Band VHF-UHF Century
Club Award. My hope is
that VHF Associations such as the SEVHFS, Central States, AMSAT, etc. would
also endorse the proposal.
Some more clarification on my suggestion to create a Five Band VHF-UHF Century
Club Award:
The main purpose of the award is to increase on-air activity both during
contests and band openings. It would also spur activity on linear satellites,
and hopefully encourage more weak signal operators to
try satellite operation.
There are more than a few operators who have already achieved VUCC on multiple
bands,
and worked a lot of grids during their careers. Some of these stations now only
get on for contests, and largely ignore band openings and day to day operation.
The award is an incentive for
these stations to return to the air since it resets everyone's score card to
zero.
My other hope is that the award will help to elevate the status of the VUCC
Award overall, and encourage more operators to get involved in VHF DXing.
1.) A requirement to include at least one of the lower VHF bands such as 6
Meters, 2 Meters, or 222 to prevent someone from simply going out with
microwave gear and earning the award
in a weekend. Personally, I would favor 2 Meters as a requirement since this is
perhaps the most difficult of the VUCC Awards to achieve and would insure the
most on-air activity.
2.) By making the award a Five Band award, you insure that at least one
microwave band will be required to earn the award, thus increasing
participation on the Microwave bands. (Technically, this
could be avoided by earning one for Satellite operation and then 902, but you
get the point)
3.) Satellite VUCC has been available since the award was created. It would remain one of
the options for earning the award and qualify as a "band" for that purpose.
Anyone who thinks Satellite work
isn't weak signal doesn't operate satellites.
4.) Resetting everyone to zero has no bearing on past VUCC award credit, FEMA
credit, or your bragging rights. It just helps to get people out of their chair
during the NFL Championship game and back
onto the air. It also simplifies the programming requirements for Logbook of
the World in implementing the new award, and makes it faster for the ARRL to
implement the new award.
5.) Endorsements for modes such as CW, digital, EME, etc. would certainly be a
good option. If anyone could earn this award on a single mode or type of
propagation my hat would really be off to you!
More likely would be endorsements for other bands, so you could have a eight
band VUCC, etc.
To work the award would need a lot of Public Relations support from the ARRL to
promote it, and build it's prestige among amateurs. Sean are you listening?
(ha, ha) VUCC has always suffered
an identity crisis among hams, and been viewed as the "little brother" to the
DXCC. The Fred Fish Memorial Award seems to have avoided that problem, and is coveted by
operators.
Have you checked the total number of VUCC Awarded once you exclude 6 Meters?
It's amazingly small on some bands---proof positive that even VHF Operators
don't always consider VUCC as
a goal. Changing the perception of the award will be an important job for the
league and VHF associations.
--
--
73,
Les Rayburn, N1LF
121 Mayfair Park
Maylene, AL 35114
EM63nf
6M VUCC #1712
AMSAT #38965
Grid Bandits #222
Southeastern VHF Society
Central States VHF Society Life Member
Six Club #2484
Active on 6 Meters thru 1296, 10GHz & Light
------
Submissions: vhf@w6yx.stanford.edu
Subscription/removal requests: vhf-request@w6yx.stanford.edu
Human list administrator: vhf-approval@w6yx.stanford.edu
List rules and information: http://www-w6yx.stanford.edu/vhf/
_______________________________________________
VHFcontesting mailing list
VHFcontesting@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/vhfcontesting
|