Another subtlety is the recent standards requirement for two hole
compression lugs plus antioxidant between surfaces for all bonding wire
terminations. I think the idea with two hole lugs is to prevent
loosening of a single bolt attachment from movement of the wire, not so
hard with 2 gauge wire.
Grant KZ1W
On 10/16/2017 5:26 AM, Ward Silver wrote:
Why would the hose clamp blow apart? I have used this method for decades
and have had multiple direct lightning strikes.
The mechanical forces on a conductor carrying kilo-amp currents from a
lightning strike can be extreme - many pounds per foot of conductor. (This
is described by Ampere's Force Law.) That's why codes require ground
conductors for lightning rods and antennas to be secured to a building or
support structure. (This was news to me, too.)
Basically, the conductor experiences a huge jerk which would destroy either
the conductor or whatever is trying to secure it - like a hose clamp. So
it would be more accurate to say that the hose clamp is not rated to
withstand the force experienced by the ground conductor and is not blown
apart by the current. It's the mechanical force.
If hose clamps have been used and the tower has taken hits without damaging
them, then the ground conductors are not for whatever reason carrying
enough of the current pulse to generate damaging forces. Or maybe the
configuration of the conductor was such that the force was weaker than it
could be. i.e. - you got lucky :-)
I'm no different in that I've used hose clamps over the years for similar
applications and got away with it. No more. As long as we're in True
Confessions mode, I've used braid from old coax (outdoors, even!) and
soft-soldered strap and braid to ground rods. No more of that, either.
Live and learn, especially now that I live back in the lightning zone
(Missouri) with towers on a high spot.
So the advice is just to use the right stuff for the job. It's not that
expensive (a lot less than your insurance deductible, that's for sure) and
has been engineered to minimize corrosion and handle the mechanical
requirements of the application.
I also got a question about CadWeld and those are great for ground
electrodes but I would never use them on the tower itself. It may be
possible to safely weld a connection to a tower but I wouldn't do it to a
tubular load-bearing leg, not to mention the dissimilar metals involved and
all that. I wouldn't want to weaken a cross-brace either, especially when
there are other options designed for that exact application. Maybe someone
with broadcast tower experience could weigh in on that. I repeat, for us
hams, just buy the right stuff and and do what the manufacturer says.
73, Ward N0AX
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
_______________________________________________
_______________________________________________
TowerTalk mailing list
TowerTalk@contesting.com
http://lists.contesting.com/mailman/listinfo/towertalk
|